 |
|
|
Casey Dumas, 31,
killed by deputy
|
|
Nov 13, 2009 - Sheriff Jack A. Stephens said he believes it was proper use of deadly force when a deputy shot to death a man on Friday morning, Nov. 13, after the man choked and slapped his estranged wife in a domestic dispute and later aimed a handgun at the responding officer outside the woman's Arabi home.
Casey Dumas, 31, of Chalmette, a pipefitter who has been arrested numerous times on alcohol-related crimes such as driving while intoxicated, battery on police and resisting police, died at the scene of the 1:30 a.m. shooting outside 846 Lebeau Street, in Old Arabi between St. Claude Avenue and the Mississippi River.
The deputy, Cpl. Marco Spicuzza, a 12-year veteran, shot Dumas twice, once in the center of the chest and once near a shoulder, when Dumas ignored several commands to drop a gun he first placed in his mouth, then aimed at the deputy, at a distance of several feet, Sheriff Stephens said in a news conference on Nov. 13.
Several people including a neighbor, the wife, Robin Menzato, who had been separated from Dumas for about a month, and the woman’s 19-year-old daughter from a previous marriage, all said they heard the deputy tell Dumas to drop the weapon, Sheriff Stephens said.
“It appears to be a good shooting,’’ Stephens said, meaning it fits the rule of deadly force being used by a law enforcement officer only when his life or a third party’s life is in danger from an attacker.
The sheriff said it seems Spicuzza took appropriate action when his life was in danger after Dumas aimed a Glock handgun at him, which was recovered at the scene, from a short distance.
Spicuzza has been placed on administrative duty and will undergo a psychiatric evaluation and go before a sheriff’s review board before he can be reinstated to duty on the streets, the sheriff said.
Stephens, sheriff of St. Bernard since 1984, said during his tenure there has been only one other case of a deputy killing someone, which happened about 10 years ago after an armed robbery of a Chalmette store in which the assailant fled to a canal in Arabi and was shot to death as he fired at officers.
Deputy Spicuzza responded to a domestic complaint call after 1 a.m. from a woman who said her husband had choked and slapped her. A neighbor confirmed seeing the argument outside and told Dumas she would call the Sheriff’s Office if he didn’t leave the wife alone.
Dumas, who had been living with his parents in Chalmette, left the scene but called back to the occupants, making threats to burn down the house with his wife inside. He made the threats even after the woman's daughter told him over the phone he should stay away because a sheriff’s deputy had arrived, with Dumas saying he was still going to come back, Sheriff Stephens said.
Deputy Spicuzza heard Dumas arrive in a vehicle out front and went onto the front porch and down the steps to speak with the husband, Stephens said.
The deputy saw Dumas approach with something in his hand. As Dimas got closer he produced a black pistol, which Dumas then put into his mouth, the sheriff said.
He said the deputy drew his weapon and ordered Dumas to drop his weapon but Dumas continued to approach in an "aggressive manner" with the gun in his mouth and then removed it and pointed the gun at the deputy. With the weapon pointed at him, Spicuzza fired at Dumas, hitting him in the chest and right shoulder, with Dumas coming into contact with Spicuzza, who then wrestled him to the ground and secured Dumas’ gun, the sheriff said.
Medical attention was given at the scene but Dumas died there.
There hasn’t been any official report from the Sheriff’s Office on whether Dumas may have fired his gun at any time.
Domestic violence calls continue to be a situation in which law enforcement officers are killed in the line of duty each year, the sheriff said. Out of concern for victims of domestic violence, the Sheriff’s Office has partnered with the Battered Women’s Shelter in St. Bernard to make sure victims are aware of options and to prosecute cases.
When passions run high in domestic situations, the sheriff said, “reason is thrown out of the window in cases like this.’’
The wife wasn’t seriously injured in the initial incident with Dumas, the sheriff said.
|